Monday, June 25, 2012

It isn't enough to tell us what a man did. You've got to tell us who he was.


Citizen Kane. It's arguably the best movie ever made according to critics and film festivals. It incorporated ground breaking cinematography, soundtrack, and storytelling. More importantly, I watched it last night, giving it more legitimacy than the reviews of Siskel, Ebert, and Jon Lovitz combined (remember he had a show? no? me neither). 

I was actually really moved by the overall message of the movie-that is, success is futile. Ok, so that's probably not what the movie's message really is, but it's along those lines. As I was watching the movie, I realized just how nerdy I'm becoming (and how much I'm craving some sort of creative medium) because I started taking notes of my favorite quotations as they were said. Before you decide to judge me, and cut off all communication with me, don't. 

I especially liked the character Jed Leland, one of Kane's closest colleagues. From the beginning of the film, Leland sort of acts as a moral critic of Kane, and tries to keep Kane in check. Eventually, because of disagreements, Leland tries to distance himself form Kane's control. We see that Kane destroyed everyone that ever got close to him; his wife, his lover, his friends, his colleagues...everyone eventually left him to try to save themselves, but were ultimately left broken or damaged. Leland said, "That's all he ever wanted out of life, was love. That's the tragedy of Charles Foster Kane, you see, he just didn't have any to give." 

Why did Kane have such a destructive influence on himself, and those around him? In the movie, he himself claims, "if I hadn't been very rich, I might have been a really great man." Kane despises even himself, and dies a lonely old man, clinging to the memory of a lost childhood. What missing pieces are there in my own life? What have I given up to gain what little I have? I think it's easy to justify changing your value system, and I also think you really ought to alter it often. It shouldn't remain the same your entire life, it should move forward, not backward, upward, not forward, and always twirling, twirling toward freedom.

The Simpsons actually did an interesting parody of the film with Mr. Burns and his lost teddy, Bobo. In this version, Burns' missing 'jigsaw piece' (see the movie, it's really pretty good) is actually returned to him, and he is content. The movie shows that the sled was stashed among Kane's mountain of possessions, meaning he had somehow obtained the left item, but not the significance it carried.

2 comments:

  1. We met these amazing people when we lived in Menlo Park. They were surrounded by so much wealth (and were themselves pretty wealthy), but they lived surprisingly modest lives. The woman once told me, "I don't understand the other women who live here. I just don't place value on material things." She was the most charitable and kind person I've ever known (seriously). Since then we've tried to live more like that couple. I love that quote from Kane that if he hadn't been wealthy, he'd probably have been a good man. I believe that's true for most people. Better to just avoid it entirely. Thank you, law school loans, for helping me avoid any temptation whatsoever. Good post, Bryce.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Citizen Kane is a direct attack on materialism and the eventuality (and unavoidability) of destruction of society when capitalism and materialism run hand in hand. It was also on the tail end of the naturalist movement and its cousin, socialism. I don't mean socialism in a pejorative sense, only that the themes are similar. It is curious to think that Kane couldn't recover what his sled represented, and I think that's what the movie is really about. Once you've really lost it, you can't ever go back. it was a cautionary tale to an America that was just entering into its adolescence and was getting very rich and very powerful. I think that's why it has endured as a classic, as well for its cinematic innovations and fine acting. Besides, Orson Welles went on to voice a character in the Transformers movie (animated). A fine end to a fine career.

    ReplyDelete